top of page

Unveiling Dark Secrets: Tragedy and Murder at the Devil’s Punch Bowl

A pallid moon casts its haunting glow over Hindhead, near Haslemere, where secrets of the past fester in the very heart of the Devil’s Punch Bowl Hotel. As one may decipher from its ominous name, this stay would prove to be more enigmatic and macabre than expected. A lingering sense of unease settled upon us, like a shroud of foreboding, as we embarked on an innocent morning stroll through the country park before our journey to Brighton. Little did we anticipate that this walk would unravel the sinister threads of an untold murder that lay buried in history's crypt.

The Devil’s Punch Bowl, a chasm gouged into the earth near Hindhead in Surrey, beckons with an eerie allure—a crater that could be mistaken for a cosmic scar or an amphitheatre built to host forbidden spectacles. Local lore whispers of the devil himself, whose domain lay at Devil’s Jumps, three miles away near Churt. His malevolent glee, it is said, manifested in leaping from hill to hill, taunting Thor, the god of thunder, residing in nearby Thursley. Thunderbolts and lightning clashed as weapons in their celestial feud, each hurling fury at the other. The devil retaliated with clutches of earth, creating a scar upon the land—a depression aptly named the Devil’s Punch Bowl. Another myth, no less sinister, paints the devil as an architect of watery wrath, a channel carved to flood the very land, birthing the enigmatic mounds that now haunt the landscape.

Held in perpetual care by the National Trust, the Devil’s Punch Bowl and Hindhead Commons seem to harbor whispers of forgotten misdeeds. Amidst a damp and dappled path, my steps, adorned in glittering pumps, tread upon the sandy trail, and it is then that I chanced upon a solitary gravestone. This stone sentinel, known as the Sailor’s Stone, commands an ethereal view of the rolling countryside, where echoes of a heinous crime resound even after centuries have slipped by.

On that fateful September day in 1786, the sailor's life hung in the balance as he traversed the ancient road from London to Portsmouth, crossing paths with three companions at the Red Lion in Thursley. Ale flowed, and revelry ensued, but the night took a grim turn. Suddenly, those companions turned malevolent, the sailor a victim of their darkest urges. The blade kissed his throat, and his lifeblood seeped into the earth beneath him. A gruesome tableau unfolded as his body was cast over the edge of the Devil’s Punch Bowl, lost to the very abyss that once bore the Devil's rage.

A macabre twist of fate would see the murderers sealed within irons, their corpses ensnared in chains, left to sway in a warning dance upon Gibbet Hill—a stern reminder to all who would walk the path of criminality. And there, beneath the gibbous moon's gaze, their malevolent journey found its culmination as the gallows embraced them.

A monument, aptly known as the Sailor's Stone, stands sentinel to this cruel fate, an epitaph etched in ink and anguish upon the tapestry of history:

"When pitying Eyes to see my Grave shall come, And with a generous Tear below my Tomb, Here shall they read my melancholy Fate, With Murder and Barbarity complete."

The unknown sailor's memory persists, a specter that roams the very grounds where his life was so callously extinguished. In 1851, a granite Celtic Cross was raised, a beacon of light intended to chase away the lingering phantoms, but shadows of the past are not so easily vanquished. Amidst the Devil’s Punch Bowl, where the devil once played his sinister game, the echoes of a sailor's tragic demise still resonate—a haunting reminder of the darkness that can permeate even the most idyllic landscapes.The baleful echo of this merciless slaughter clung to the very spot where the nameless mariner met his cruel destiny, an imprint etched onto the fabric of time itself. Tales of specters and the uncanny began to weave amongst the villagers like a shroud, a whispering dread that haunted the edges of their waking hours and the veil of their dreams, all born of the crime's malevolent aura. Ghostly apparitions and otherworldly murmurs kept vigil near the scene, their presence instilling terror in the hearts of those who dared wander by the scene of the sinister act.

And then, as the moon's pale fingers brushed the edge of a new century, the year 1851 cast its shadow upon the land. It was then that a solemn granite Celtic Cross emerged from the earth, a sentinel of stone erected near the very place where the gibbet stood. Its purpose, much like the soul of the lamented sailor, was to quell the whispers that danced on the lips of the villagers, to bring solace to a land shrouded in sorrow, to chase away the phantoms of the past and instill hope once more.

With measured steps, I ascended the somber hill, my footfalls like whispers upon the soil. There, atop the hill's crest, the Celtic Cross rose—a sentinel of memory, a beacon against the encroaching darkness. Yet, even in this gesture of defiance, a silent epitaph in the tongue of Latin carved into the stone spoke volumes. It bore witness to the curse and the blessing, the remembrance and the forgetting, the shadow and the light that embraced this land, forever intertwined in an eternal dance.

An excerpt of the Latin inscription reads:

"Post Tenebras, Lux,

Veritas in Silentio,

Memoria in Lapide."


"After Darkness, Light,

Truth in Silence,

Memory in Stone."

Footnote: This is a peaceful place despite its tragic and violent history. It was also interesting to learn that this relatively unknown murder had inspired Charles Dickens. In Nicholas Nickleby, Nicholas stops at the Sailor’s Stone with Smike on their way to Portsmouth:

The grass on which they stood, had once been dyed with gore; and the blood of the murdered man had run down, drop by drop, into the hollow which gives the place its name. “The Devil’s Bowl”, thought Nicholas, as he looked into the void, “never held fitter liquor than that!” Nicholas Nickleby, Charles Dickens, 1839


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page